Toad & Fish Bakery is a small, heart-led bakery started by two people who love each other very much, and who love good food even more.
​
The bakery was founded by Karri, an artist at heart who has always found creativity and comfort in the kitchen. Baking has long been a way to slow down, work with her hands, and make something meaningful to share. What began as a personal passion gradually grew into a dream of building something intentional, community-focused, and full of care.
Miriam is the heart behind the scenes, Karri’s biggest supporter, taste-tester, and ever-patient little sous chef. Whether it’s helping with prep, offering encouragement, or simply being there through late baking nights, Miriam is a constant part of the process and the reason this bakery feels like home.
​
Together, we focus on small-batch baked goods made with quality ingredients and thoughtful technique. Our menu features comforting classics like breads, bagels, muffins, and babkas — foods meant to be shared, enjoyed, and returned to again and again.
Toad & Fish Bakery is about more than just baked goods. It’s about care, creativity, and building something meaningful together. We’re so grateful to have you here and to share what we love with you.
​
Who We Are
Who We Are
Based in Indianapolis, Indiana 🌽
Named after our cat, Toad, and our puppy, Fish, Toad & Fish Bakery is a small, heart-led bakery started by two people who love each other very much, and who love good food even more.
​
The bakery was founded by Karri, an artist at heart who has always found creativity and comfort in the kitchen. Baking has long been a way to slow down, work with her hands, and make something meaningful to share. What began as a personal passion gradually grew into a dream of building something intentional, community-focused, and full of care.
​
Miriam is the heart behind the scenes, Karri’s biggest supporter, taste-tester, and ever-patient little sous chef. Whether it’s helping with prep, offering encouragement, or simply being there through late baking nights, Miriam is a constant part of the process and the reason this bakery feels like home.
​
Together, we focus on small-batch baked goods made with quality ingredients and thoughtful technique. Our menu features comforting classics like breads, bagels, muffins, and babkas, foods meant to be shared, enjoyed, and returned to again and again.
​
Toad & Fish Bakery is about more than just baked goods. It’s about care, creativity, and building something meaningful together. We’re so grateful to have you here and to share what we love with you.
​
TOAD
FISH
